Hey Patricia!
First of all, congrats on being bitten by the print bug. Secondly, these are both decent prices. Rollers will cost you a couple hundred bucks for the Craftsman, but it’s a bit stronger press than the Kelsey. You’ll need to spend some more money though, to really get started. I’d budget for an extra $300-400 in additional supplies, depending on what accessories the seller throws in with your press. You’ll need:
– ink
– tympan and packing material
– gauge pins (I recommend Henry)
– a Boxcar base or similar if you plan to print your own designs using photopolymer
– roller height gauge
– quoins and quoin key
– furniture (for locking up your form)
– line gauge (a fancy printer’s ruler)
– oil (3in1 is great)
– solvent for clean-up (mineral spirits, California Wash, etc.)
As a caveat, I’d like to give you some realistic expectations of what a 5×8 tabletop can produce. If you’re looking for a deep impression (a bite), you’ll be very limited on how large an image you can print. I have a couple of Adanas that I use for teaching, and one of them was my starter press. I limit size to no more than about 6-8sq inches, less if the image is a high solid area. For small designs on notecards, a 5×8 would be perfect. For a more elaborate wedding invitation, for instance, you may push the upper limits of what a little tabletop can produce.
Hope that helps, and keep us posted!