Thanks so much! I did a look through Finish Finder (great resource!) but didn’t have much luck. I am really happy to know about Hodgins though. Many thanks!
I was previously using Nostalgic Impressions, but have found it necessary to find an alternative source. I recently got a sample pack from Wax Works (http://www.waxseals.com) and thought they were lovely. I will likely order from them next time, although they are in Canada.
You may have already figured this out, but USPS just adds $0.20 to the postage since it’s non-machinable with the wax seal. And the real wax seals will break, so I always use the faux wax with the peel and seal option. I’ve used the faux seals on the exterior as well.