I wonder why I wasnt sent an email with these replies! Thank you everyone. The weird thing is, I think it is my rollers on my C&P. I even took a ton of ink off the press and was still getting the splotchy coverage. I tried it on my 3×5 Kelsey and the ink coverage was great (no impression to speak of though).
I had some soy based ink custom mixed by Great Western Ink and got the same splotchy result on the C&P. Could it be my rollers?
Kseniya, I am going to try your method with my custom ink.
Annika, I would love to have a go-to shimmer paper. I have a curious swatch book that I will try a sample on.
Camille, I had heard about the Tough Tex and called all over my town to find it to no avail. Thank you for the link. I will use that in the future if I print on Stardream again.